Dear @AbdulElSayed: 1) Israel does grant equal rights to all of its citizens. 20% of Israelis are not Jewish. Muslim Israelis serve in the military, in the Knesset, are university valedictorians, etc. Non-Jews in Israel have infinite more rights than non-Muslims in the 56 Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) countries. 2) Most of the 56 OIC countries are precisely organized along faith (Islam). Hence, are you suggesting that 2 billion Muslims are allowed to live according to Islamic rules but 15 million Jews are not allowed to have a single ancestral swath of land, the size of New Jersey. The land of Israel is the DEFINITION of an indigenous people returning to their native land. Islam is 1,400 years old. The land of Israel (and Judaism) precedes it by thousands of years. 3) Rather than swim in your Jew-hatred (masquerading as concern for a made up people known as Palestinians), be grateful that you were permitted to flourish in the United States. Stop obsessing about Jewish self-determination, and seek to look beyond your genocidal Islamic supremacy.
— Gad Saad (@GadSaad) November 18, 2026
Kali Robinson of the Council on Foreign Relations, tilting anti-Israel notes
The overwhelming majority are the remnants and descendants of the Arabs who stayed within the borders Israel declared after the 1948 Arab-Israeli war. The state of Israel was created out of the British Mandate of Palestine, then home to about 1.2 million Arabs. After more than 700,000 of them were expelled or departed in what Arabs call the nakba, or catastrophe, about 150,000 remained [PDF] within the portion of mandatory Palestine that would become the state of Israel, and they automatically became citizens, forming about half of Israel’s population.
Tilting anti-Israel/pro-Arab, Robinson maintains
Palestinians and their descendants have no legal rights to return to the lands their families held before being deisplaced in 1948 or 1967. The former returns to the alleged "nakba," in which Arab Palestinians fled their homes under threat from the Israeli government or as they were encouraged
The day after Israel declared its independence on May 15, 1948, five Arab countries invaded Israel and according to an American lawyer writing in 2003 in The Jerusalem Post, Arab leaders
encouraged Arabs living in Israel to get out of the way of
the advancing Arab armies and promised them that they would be able to return
after quickly winning the war. For instance, then-Iraqi prime minister Nuri
Said was quoted saying, “We will smash the country with our guns and obliterate
every place the Jews seek shelter in. The Arabs should conduct their wives and
children to safe areas until the fighting has died down.
Catastrophe or strategic abandonment- you make the call. Robinson explains
Israel’s establishment as an explicitly Jewish state is a
primary point of contention, with many of the state’s critics arguing that this
by nature casts non-Jews as second-class citizens with fewer rights. The 1950
Law of Return, for example, grants all Jews, as well as their children,
grandchildren, and spouses, the right to move to Israel and automatically gain
citizenship. Non-Jews do not have these rights. Palestinians and their
descendants have no legal right to return to the lands their families held
before being displaced in 1948 or 1967.
Displaced- or encouraged to ditch their homes by an Arabic establishment which wanted to starve the nascent state of many of its workers to accomplish what their armies could not. As you make this call, recall that Robinson's primary beef with the Jewish nation is that it grants Jews from across the globe an extraordinary right to "move to Israel and automatically gain citizenship". Muslims wishing to do so can establish citizenship on the same basis that, for example, immigrants to the USA can.
Robinson also points out
Statistics from IDI show that Arab citizens of Israel continue to face structural disadvantages. For example, poorly funded schools in their localities contribute to their attaining lower levels of education and their reduced employment prospects and earning power compared to Israeli Jews. More than half of the country's Arab families were considered poor in 2020, compared to 40 percent of Jewish families.
That's more than half of Arab families vs. 40% of Jewish families. Israel, has not, it appears, attained a socialist or Marxist Valhalla. Please wake me when educational levels and employment opportunites are equally distributed among all ethnic groups in the USA, the world's largest and greatest representative democracy.
No doubt there are popular or scholarly articles suggesting that Israeli Arabs have rights and opportunities equal to those of Israeli Jews. However, Robinson's piece is slanted toward Israeli Arabs as she laments unequal attainment between the two groups and unusual privileges granted to Jews.
An individual who is poised to become a United States Senator sees that and whines that Israel does not "uphold equal rights for all of its citizens," rights which exceed those granted Muslims anywhere else in the Middle East, and implies that those other nations do not identify itself with a culture or a faith. Nakba? How about this for a "nakba"?
Until the 1960s, approximately one million Jews lived in
Iran and other Arab countries having arrived in the region more than 2,000
years before. Nowadays, it is estimated that only around 15,000 remain, as the
majority of the Jewish population in Muslim lands were forced to flee their
homes in the years following the establishment of the State of Israel. This
mass expulsion and exodus is part of modern history, but inexplicably, it’s
neither taught at schools nor remembered within the context of the conflicts in
the Middle East.
For over 2,500 years, Jews lived continuously in North Africa, the Middle East and the Gulf region the first Jewish population had already settled there at least 1,000 years before the advent of Islam.
Throughout the generations, Jews in the region were often
subjected to various forms of discrimination -- and in many cases, ranked lower
on the status of society than their Muslim compatriots -- but they were
nevertheless loyal citizens who contributed significantly to the culture and
development of their respective countries.
Despite the positive influence that Jews brought to the places where they lived, more than 850,000 Jews were forced to leave their homes in Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Libya, Morocco, and several other Arab countries in the 20 years that followed the Arab-Israeli war of 1948. Another major forced migration took place from Iran in 1979–80, following the Iranian Revolution and the collapse of the shah’s regime, adding 70,000 more Jewish refugees to this number.
(Note: Iran is Persian, not Arab, point nevertheless made.)
But when asked about whether Israel has a right to exist, el-Sayed never has given an unqualified answer in the affirmative. And that question, as posed, should be easy to answer: he never has been asked whether Israel should exist as a Jewish state. It's an easy question for the random tweeter who is a scientist, who exaggerates about Israel-sightly.
Acceptance of Israel as a Jewish state should should be easy for an incoming Senator. Not, however, for Abdul el-Sayed, who wants a Palestinan, obviously Muslim, state. Jews need not apply.
