Friday, November 13, 2026

The Deceit Rolls On


Nice try, Mehdi. But you're wrong as usual on the Hamas-Israel war.

 


In September of 2025, John Spencer and Arsen Ostrovsky wrote

Under the 1948 Genocide Convention, genocide is not a vague political term but a tightly defined legal crime: acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group. The critical element is specific intent, what international tribunals have called dolus specialis. This “intent to destroy” requirement is deliberately set as a very high bar. Without it, mass atrocities, however horrific, fall under other categories of international law, such as war crimes or crimes against humanity, but not genocide.

Nothing we have seen in Gaza remotely approaches proof of genocidal intent or action. The war is ugly, painful, and devastating, but it is fought by Israel in self-defense and in accordance with the laws of armed conflict. Hamas carried out the single worst massacre of Jews since the Holocaust on October 7, 2023, has vowed to repeat it “again and again” until Israel is annihilated, and still holds dozens of hostages.

And nothing in the past 14 months has changed that. But if Israel has committed actual genocide, someone should notify pro-Muslim Palestinian senator-elect Abdul el-Sayed, who in September admitted "the whole point of creating that word isn't that you have to wait until the crime is that big again to be able to use, otherwise it loses its power. It's power is in making a thing before it gets that big, so we could do something about it".

Translated: we have to use the word "genocide" because of its power to prevent it from occurring. If those obsessed with "Zionism" and "Zionists" have lost the Senator-elect, they should reconsider. After all, el-Sayed has long accused Israel of committing genocide- since at least October 21, 2023, a mere two weeks after Hamas' deadly attack upon the Jews of southern Israel,

Spencer and Ostrovsky conclude "Words matter. So does law.  Genocide is not a political football. They were two-thirds right. Words matter and law matters but genocide has become a political football, for at least the past 37 months.



No comments:

Campaign to Annihilate People With the Wrong Religion

Who is correct- some random guy, identifying as an "evolutionary behavioral scientist" or a medical doctor, now freely-elected Un...